Following a right hemisphere stroke, a woman has left-sided paralysis and sensory loss. She acknowledges that the arm lying beside her cannot move, but insists with complete conviction that it is not her own arm — she says it belongs to the nurse and was left there by mistake. What is this?
This is somatoparaphrenia: a confidently held false belief that a limb does not belong to the person, often with a specific alternative explanation of whose limb it supposedly is, typically alongside paralysis and sensory loss following a right hemisphere lesion. It is not anosognosia, which denies that a deficit such as paralysis exists at all — here she accepts the arm is impaired, she simply denies it is hers. It is not hemiasomatognosia, which is a passive lack of felt ownership rather than an active, elaborated false belief about whose limb it is. And it is not a delusion of persecution, since there is no belief of being targeted or harmed here, only a false belief about the arm's ownership.
References
- Casey, P. & Kelly, B. (2019). Fish's Clinical Psychopathology, 4th ed. Ch. 3, 'Disorders of Perception'.